Penang need not pay Perak until water supply starts, says Chow
Payments under the bulk water agreement would require SPAN approval, while PBAPP could invoke termination provisions over breaches that remain unremedied.

Penang has no obligation to pay Perak before deliveries begin under the Bulk Water Supply Agreement (BWSA), Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow said, rejecting allegations of annual RM210 million payments over 40 years even without water being supplied.
In a statement, Chow said payments would require approval from the National Water Services Commission (SPAN). He was responding to Bagan member of Parliament Lim Guan Eng, who he said had continued to allege unethical practices despite repeated explanations.
Chow, who chairs both Penang Water Supply Corporation (PBAPP) and PBA Holdings Bhd (PBAHB), said PBAPP's board had unanimously approved the proposed agreement. At PBAHB's extraordinary general meeting on Nov 12, the proposal received support from 98% of shareholders.
PBAHB's board backed the proposal by seven to five, he said. The objections from its five independent directors concerned particular payment terms, which he said had been addressed in specific contractual clauses.
Chow said the arrangement would provide Penang with water infrastructure capacity without requiring it to shoulder all construction costs and initial development risks. PBAPP could take contractual action, including invoking termination provisions, over obligations breached and not remedied as required by the agreement. Penang therefore would not necessarily remain liable for payments until 2072, he said.


